Chat with us, powered by LiveChat

King Felix Sunday Bebor Berebon & Ors v The Shell Petroleum Development Company of Nigeria Ltd [2017] EWHC 1579 (TCC)

Comment on without prejudice nature of mediation

Coulson J considered whether it would be wrong in principle not to lift a stay merely because of the claimants' conduct in a mediation.  Claimants' counsel submitted that such conduct might be reflected in costs but that it would be erroneous in principle for that conduct to reflect on the claimants' substantive rights.  Coulson J agreed that it would be unusual for a court to prevent a claimant who had acted badly in a mediation from pursuing his underlying substantive claim as a result.  He noted that, more often than not, the court will have very little idea of what happened in a mediation because it will be covered by the 'without prejudice' tag.

More Cases

Subject
Consideration as to whether a failure to respond to an offer to mediate is, in itself, unreasonable conduct which should lead to cost sanctions. Costs awarded to the successful party on an indemnity basis despite failure to mediate.
Subject
Costs decision. Consideration of validity of Part 36 offer and reasonableness of failure to mediate at an earlier stage.
Subject
Indemnity costs ordered on basis that losing party failed to engage with offer to mediate.

accreditations & partnerships